...

Alberta is giving another handout to oil companies

Alberta Premier Danielle Smith at the podium Friday afternoon, November 13, flanked by her ministers of energy and finance, and supported by a chorus line of oil industry execs who in turn carried by a number of current workers.
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith at the podium Friday afternoon, November 13, flanked by her ministers of energy and finance, and supported by a chorus line of oil industry execs who in turn carried by a number of current workers.

The Alberta government’s new “Oil Sands Growth Program” has turned out pretty much as expected: We will lower the province’s already low royalty rates in the hope that oil sands companies will promise to create enough new jobs to give voters a reason to re-elect the United Conservative Party (UCP).

We won’t give the stuff away entirely, but as the vendors on the beach in Mexico say about their T-shirts, a two percent royalty for five years will be “practically free.” After that, the royalties paid by some of the most profitable companies in the world will increase ever so slowly by one percent a year until they reach a maximum of six percent.

As Janetta McKenzie, director of the Calgary-based Pembina Institute’s oil and gas program, says, “This new royalty system will return even less of the oil value to Albertans and even more to corporate shareholders.”

“At a time when families are enduring an unprecedented cost of living crisis, many will question why even more of their tax dollars are being given to oil companies that are enjoying historic profits,” said Dr. McKenzie.

Of course, UCP strategists are counting on Alberta voters to do no such thing. They may very well be right.

Needless to say, unlike the analyst of the clean energy think tank, the phalanx of Big Oil bosses who lined up at the government conference in Calgary to support Premier Danielle Smith, Energy Minister Brian Jean and Finance Minister Jason Nixon practically celebrated themselves, metaphorically, during the hour and five minutes of mutual admiration and happy conversations.

In fact, the whole production yesterday looked a bit like a Broadway musical, with the smiling Prime Minister on the podium, flanked by her energy and finance ministers, alternately backed by a chorus line of Oilpatch bigshots. All it really needed was for the lineup of anonymous workers behind them in UCP blue coveralls and white hardhats to sing!

But the claims made in the press release of the government that this great gift will potentially Generating “about $205 billion in cumulative additional revenue by 2040 and over $1.3 trillion by 2060” sounds fantastic, as does Nixon’s suggestion in response to a reporter’s question that the resulting investment could create as many as 600,000 new jobs.

Any theoretical benefits for taxpayers are years away, as is always the case in such matters as this. The big payoff for giant oil sands companies will be closer. The question is whether voters will believe the hopium peddled by the Prime Minister and her ministerial sidekicks.

Could happen. It has been known to work before.

Premier Smith claimed during the news conference that Alberta will just put its cuts on hold for a little while. “It just delays the amount of additional new revenue coming in,” she quipped. Readers are invited to believe that if they wish.

To return to Dr. McKenzie’s analysis, she noted that “Alberta taxpayers are already footing the bill for large investment tax credits, a $43 billion pipeline that private investors would not touch, tens of thousands of inactive and unsafe wells, and hundreds of millions of dollars in unpaid municipal taxes from the energy sector.”

“Now,” she continued, “taxpayers are being asked to continue subsidizing the oil industry to fill another taxpayer-subsidized pipeline.”

“The provincial government has not presented any evidence to show that the existing royalty system is an obstacle to investment in the oil sands or in conventional production,” said Dr. McKenzie added. “At a time when the industry is collecting billions in windfall profits due to the conflict in the Middle East, the private sector is absolutely capable of financing production expansion if they believe in sustainable long-term oil demand.”

Ah, but do they? The current conflict in West Asia may actually have something to do with it. While the giveaway — pardon, investment enhancement — aims to create a stable environment that encourages oil companies to stay in Alberta while Smith achieves her ambition to double our oil sands output, its success still depends on sustained demand and continued high prices.

One of these days, maybe sooner than later, the US will end the war against Iran and prices may settle down after that. Moreover, when the Ukraine conflict comes to an end, Russian energy can go back to the factories of the Rhine unvexed.

With the factors that Dr.

Is the UCP brain trust nervous this could happen on their watch?

The post Alberta gives another handout to oil companies appeared first on rabble.ca.

Leave a Comment

Seraphinite AcceleratorBannerText_Seraphinite Accelerator
Turns on site high speed to be attractive for people and search engines.