In response to Alan Milburn’s landmark review into England’s youth crisis – almost a million young people aged 16-24 in the UK are not in education, work or training – Prime Minister Andy Burnham promised a “whole childhood approach”.
The intention is to prevent young people from ‘falling through the cracks’ by supporting those with special needs.
We know that young people who experience poverty, poor mental health or special educational needs and disabilities are more likely to fail.
But these risk factors only tell part of the story. Two young people can have similar disadvantages and go down very different paths. One goes to further education or work, while the other becomes neet. For what?
In our recent research, we found a gap between our ability to identify young people at risk of becoming homeless and our ability to understand what is happening to them. While the data can identify patterns of risk and disadvantage, no single data set provides the combination of long-term evidence, contextual information and population coverage needed to explain why some young people become or remain naïve while others with seemingly similar circumstances do not.
This distinction may sound technical, but it is central to effective politics. Identifying risk is not the same as understanding pathways.
What the data can – and can’t – tell us
The evidence available to researchers is often very good at identifying inequalities. We reviewed 861 records and identified 36 datasets relevant to understanding Neet levels among 16-to-24-year-olds in England.
The datasets we examined include national studies that follow young people over time, such as the Millennium Cohort Study, to large household surveys such as Understanding Society. We also reviewed records collected regularly from schools, government departments such as the Department for Education and the Department for Work and Pensions, and other public services.
While only four of the 36 identified datasets directly measured Neet status, others included information about groups at greater risk of becoming Neet, broader information about young people’s circumstances and, in some cases, how their lives have changed over time.
Taken together, these sources provide a valuable picture of young people’s circumstances and outcomes such as patterns and characteristics that help policymakers identify who may require additional support.
But our review revealed a gap: the data available are much better at identifying which young people are at risk of becoming homeless than at explaining why people diverge their paths.
A dataset could show that school absence and a period of absence occur together, or that certain groups have higher rates of education, work or training. What it often cannot show is what happened between those two points in time.
Gorgev/Shutterstock
Are young people being bullied? Were their support needs recognized? Was support available during a critical transition? These questions are often difficult to answer through administrative records alone.
Our previous work illustrates this challenge.
Using linked administrative data, we found that young people with a history of special educational needs and disabilities (Send) were about twice as likely to be ‘needs’ as those without.
Childhood poverty further increased this risk. Among young men with both a send record and a history of free school meal eligibility, around one in four were no, compared to less than one in 14 among those with neither characteristic.
These findings highlight important inequalities and help identify groups that face greater barriers in the transition to adulthood. But they do not explain why one young person with these characteristics becomes a Neet while another does not. A characteristic can help identify risk, but it should not be treated as a prediction of an individual’s future.
What evidence is missing?
Our findings do not suggest that England simply needs more data. Instead, they point to the need for evidence designed around ways of understanding.
A priority is to follow the youth over time. A snapshot showing someone is aged 18 cannot tell us whether they have recently left education, experienced repeated periods of redundancy or are about to re-enter education, training or work.
Another is to understand the context. Administrative records can identify patterns, but they rarely capture how educational experiences, local opportunities, family responsibilities, and support systems interact.
The perspectives of the young people themselves are equally important. Interviews, participatory research and accessible surveys can reveal experiences that administrative systems rarely capture, including support that arrives late, services that are difficult to access or opportunities that are not available when needed.
Understanding institutional responses is also important. Recording a referral or intervention is not the same as knowing whether support was provided, whether it met a young person’s needs or whether it improved outcomes.
Alan Milburn’s government commission review of youth unemployment makes a compelling case that youth unemployment should not be understood as an individual failure. Our research suggests that there is another challenge: even if we know which groups have greater risks, do we have the evidence to understand where support breaks down and what makes a difference?
A connected system requires more than the ability to identify young people who may struggle. It requires learning from their experiences, the barriers they encounter and the support that helps them move into education, training or work.
England can count how many young people are left behind. The next challenge is to understand why, and what can be done differently to change the path they follow.