NEW YORK (AP) — A federal appeals court is weighing whether it can — or should — intervene in President Donald Trump’s hush money case now that a New York state appeals court has heard arguments in its quest to overturn the historic conviction.
A three-judge panel of the 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals on Monday spent more than an hour questioning Trump’s lawyer and a state attorney general about the president’s latest bid to move the case from state court to federal court, where he could try to dismiss it on immunity grounds. There was no immediate decision.
The sides were in court for the second time in 11 days as Trump pursued a two-pronged legal strategy in an attempt to get the May 2024 ruling thrown out. Trump was convicted of 34 felony counts of falsifying business records to hide a $130,000 payment to adult film performer Stormy Daniels.
READ MORE: Trump loses yet again in bid to remove his prison sentence
Along with his federal court fight, the Republican president also makes a traditional appeal through New York’s state court system, which arguments before the mid-level appeals division on November 5. That court has yet to rule.
Regardless of the outcome, Trump will forever be associated with the case that went to trial as he campaigned for his return to the White House. Trump denied wrongdoing and received no punishment. Now, a little more than two years into his presidency, he is determined to rid himself of the dubious distinction of being the first US president to be convicted of a crime.
Trump’s lawyer says the case could go to the Supreme Court
Trump’s lawyer, Robert Giuffra Jr., urged the 2nd Circuit judge on Monday to issue an order as soon as possible – even before they write their full decision – to take control of the case and stop the appellate division’s deliberations.
Without federal court intervention, Trump “will likely have to wait years” for state appeals courts to rule out before he can take the matter to the U.S. Supreme Court, Giuffra said in a letter previewing his argument.
But Judge John M. Walker Jr., who was appointed to the appeals court by his cousin, President George HW Bush, and Chief Justice Raymond J. Lohier Jr., who was appointed by President Barack Obama, were not so sure.
“How does that work?” Walker asked. “I think assuming we would agree with you, there was an argument in the Appellate Division. Briefs were filed in the Appellate Division. Are those briefs being refiled by anyone here?”
Federal law does not spell out exactly how such a move would play out.
Giuffra suggested that the case would first go to a federal court judge, who would adopt the state court ruling, before going to the 2. The shorts, he said, would remain the same – but with different covers.
“You’re asking us to bypass an entire procedural mechanism that I don’t see authorized anywhere by Congress,” Lohier said.
“We think it’s authorized,” Giuffra said, calling a provision of the law that allows such post-judgment transfer petitions “a safety valve that’s meant to protect against exactly the kind of gambling that went on here.”
A federal judge rejected Trump’s transfer offer 3 times
Trump asked the 2nd Circuit to step in after a federal judge ruled against the president for a third time in August. Judge Alvin K. Hellerstein, who died last month at the age of 92, wrote in his decision that “paying money to an adult movie star or polluting an embarrassment is not subject to presidential immunity.”
Trump first tried to move the case to federal court weeks after he was indicted in March 2023. He tried again after his conviction and the Supreme Court’s July 2024 ruling that presidents and ex-presidents cannot be prosecuted for official actions and prosecutors cannot use official actions as evidence that unofficial actions were illegal.
Giuffra argued to both state and federal appeals panels that prosecutors used the kind of official action evidence that was later blocked by the Supreme Court’s immunity ruling, including testimony about his Oval Office conversations, workflow and social media posts.
Giuffra also took issue with the prosecutor’s description of the hush money payment as an illegal campaign contribution under federal election campaign law, arguing that such charges belong in federal court, not state court.
After Trump appealed Hellerstein’s second denial, the 2nd Circuit ordered the judge to reconsider, finding that he had not weighed “important issues relevant” to the president’s request to move the case.
That panel, which also includes Lohier, said it did not express an opinion on how he should rule, but instructed Hellerstein to review evidence that Trump claimed to be related to official actions and whether Trump could argue that those actions were taken as part of his duties in the White House.
Steven Wu, head of the appellate division in the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office, has 2. Even if Trump prevails, he argued, the state appeals court would still be free to rule.
A free press is a cornerstone of a healthy democracy.
Support trustworthy journalism and civil dialogue.