Jurors heard the defendant thought people were accusing him of being a pedophile
A man who stabbed 10 people on a train thought everyone was part of a “conspiracy organized by the devil against him”, a court heard. The defense case in the Anthony Williams trial has called a psychiatric expert to give evidence at Cambridge Crown Court today (November 17).
Williams, 33, denies 10 counts of attempted murder in connection with the attack on the LNER train, and a further four counts which occurred before the train attack. However, he admitted 14 counts of wounding with intent.
Consultant forensic psychiatrist Dr Bernard Chin, who assessed Williams and saw much of the evidence, was called to give evidence. Jurors heard the doctor was “satisfied” Williams was “suffering from an acute relapse of schizophrenia at the time of each alleged offence”. Evidence from Dr Chin said a report by psychiatrist Dr Alan Smith dated November 2 last year, when Williams was in prison, noted that the defendant thought everyone was part of a “conspiracy organized by the devil against him”.
Dr. Smith’s report also said Williams “had stopped his quetiapine, the medicine, three days before as it did not work although he recognized the voices worsened after. Gillian Jones, KC, defending, saw Williams in person at Rampton Hospital in June.
Continuing through Dr Smith’s report, the jury heard that during the course of the incidents, Williams contacted his GP on several occasions to “underline his deteriorating mental state”. Ms Jones said Williams said his “medication wasn’t working and he wanted it changed”. The GP “found that he only took 100mg and needed to take 200mg”.
The court heard that the accused was sent a letter inviting him to a meeting on October 14, but he did not respond to the letter or attend. He was offered an appointment on November 5, which was after the incidents.
Dr Chin said Williams told him he was “paranoid” and thought people were after me. The defendant believed there was a “conspiracy accusing him of being a pedophile.”
The jury was told Williams thought his house was “watched” and slept outside in the woods, despite still hearing voices. Dr Chin said Williams claimed it was “really bad on Halloween, it gets tougher”. He was “extremely paranoid” and thought: “People were after me, cars were after me, I was going to be run over by cars”.
He said he brought knives from home and “walked through the river as I know the cars couldn’t rush me there”. Dr Chin said Williams suggested “the voices said I was going to be attacked”. He also watched a TikTok video showing “someone stabbing someone” and believed it was a ‘warning’ to him.
Referring to the November 1 mob attack, jurors heard Dr. Chin recall the defendant saying: “I don’t remember why I got back on the train. I barely remember anything from when the incident started. I just keep hearing ‘you’re going to be attacked,’ they’re going to kill you” through the train’s speakers.
The doctor said Williams said: “I attacked people, they were real people, I had knives, real knives, and knew they were going to attack me.” He always heard ‘You are a [paedophile]’ through the train loudspeakers. He said he heard Williams state, “I wasn’t really thinking at the time. I just needed to protect myself. It was me or her.”
The jury heard that Williams “received messages and meaning from seemingly unrelated things like the TikTok video”. Dr Chin said the defendant believed his thoughts were being “broadcasted” so people could hear what he was thinking.
Dr. Chin said he diagnosed Williams with schizophrenia, and that was an opinion shared with a psychiatrist instructed by the prosecution. Dr Chin explained that Williams “had what we call paranoid delusions of persecution, meaning he had ideas and beliefs that people were going to harm him and that this was an organized conspiracy that came about because of … the devil”.
Ms Jones asked Dr Chin about the role of alcohol, but he said it “wouldn’t have caused it, it wouldn’t have provoked it, if anything it would have made him a bit more agitated”. Dr Chin agreed that the defense of insanity was not available to Williams, and it was “evident that Mr Williams knew the nature and quality of his act and he knew what he was doing was legally wrong”.
The expert witness believes that Williams had the capacity to form the intent, but that the matter is up to the jury to decide. He said there was “nothing to suggest by reason of his mental disorder that he was incapable of forming the relevant intention”. He agreed with Ms Jones that a “psychotic intent is still an intent”.
Ms Jones told jurors: “I will not be calling Mr Williams to give evidence.”
The judge, Mr Justice Calver, told jurors they could not hold this against Williams in any way, adding: “I will give you direction on that in due course.”
The jury was adjourned until Thursday, when he should begin the first part of his summing up. The process continues.
Want all the latest Cambridgeshire news in your inbox? Then do CambridgeshireLive Your favorite source of news on Google. You can do this by clicking on the link here.