“There will be people in the future who won’t get what they get today”
Some young people may no longer be entitled to their current benefits, as Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden said a “complete reset” of the system was required to support the current level of 16-24-year-olds not in education, work or training.
With the number of so-called NEETs surpassing one million earlier this year, a ‘landmark review’ of the issue by Alan Milburn is scheduled to be published on Tuesday, which is widely expected to introduce major changes in light of youth unemployment.
Don’t let an algorithm decide what Manchester news you see – click here to add the MEN as your preferred Google source
The former Labor health secretary was tasked with carrying out the review after fears of a backbench rebellion led Sir Keir Starmer’s government to scale back some of his welfare proposals.
Mr Milburn indicated that his proposals would result in less financial help for young people if implemented, with pressure to move them away from health-related benefits and onto a new “youth allowance” paid at the standard Universal Credit rate.
When asked if he agreed that some individuals should lose the welfare they currently receive, he told the BBC’s Sunday With Laura Kuenssberg show: “There will be people in the future who won’t get what they get today.
“When people come to a reassessment, they go on to a new system, but, as I say, people are being reassessed today under the current system.”
Andy Burnham described the politically sensitive report as a “watershed” moment, but did not commit to accepting its recommendations in their entirety.
The prime minister insisted that funding the reforms did not require “more money” but rather “spending differently” within government when asked about the substantial upfront investment required.
Mr McFadden argued that ministers must pursue reforms not “despite being Labor people” but “because we are Labor people”, following concerns about whether the government would be able to secure the support of its own MPs for changes.
“If you’re 20 now and you sign up for long-term sickness benefits, you have a better chance of hitting your 30th birthday and still being on them than a steady job in between,” he said.
Mr Milburn argued that young people deserve a “statutory guarantee” of work, training or employment support. He assured the BBC that the government would avoid “the elephant trap” of young people pursuing legal action when no opportunities are available to them, saying: “We will have a duty to the government to provide opportunities.”
“We call it the opportunity guarantee, so it should be a guarantee for a young person, because at the moment the only guarantee they get is on a very simple thing, getting a benefit.”
Shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately said creating a statutory right “might sound like a nice thing to do” but “makes no sense”.
However, other aspects of Mr Milburn’s approach were cautiously endorsed by the Conservative frontbencher, who said his emphasis on moving from “spending money for relatively soft conditions” towards employment support “was the right direction of travel”.
“We think he should do it for all ages, not just under 25. You shouldn’t have a different system for a 24-year-old and a 26-year-old,” she told Sky.