[Editor’s note: Steve Burgess is an accredited spin doctor with a PhD in Centrifugal Rhetoric from the University of SASE, situated on the lovely campus of PO Box 7650, Cayman Islands. In this space he dispenses PR advice to politicians, the rich and famous, the troubled and well-heeled, the wealthy and gullible.]
Dear Dr. Steve,
Federal Environment Minister Julie Dabrusin says Canada is committed to meeting our goals in the Paris Climate Agreement. But two former environment ministers, Catherine McKenna and Steven Guilbeault, call bullshit. They say the Carney government is making little or no effort to limit emissions. Last week, McKenna posted online: “Canada now has zero chance of meeting its 2030 Paris commitment and has no way to reach net zero by 2050 (and this is before any new oil sands or LNG).”
Is Canada still one of the good guys?
signed,
Angel
Dear Angie,
Sorting out the heroes from the villains can be quite confusing these days. Most of us are still trying to wrap our heads around the fact that America and Russia are now besties. It’s like one of those rom-coms where two people start off very wrong – maybe one even calls the other the “evil empire” – but in the last scene they end up laughing, holding hands and denying freedom to the people of Ukraine. Roll Credits.
Ideally, good and bad should be well marked. There is often a hat-based color scheme. Back then it was white hat good, black hat bad – more recently red hats have also become suspect. And as that famous Mitchell and Webb skit says, when your hats have skulls on, you should probably ask yourself some hard questions.
But Canadians are pretty comfortable about our role, especially in the Donald Trump era. You will know us from our enemies. Trump is a hideous, man-sized toad, and he hates Canada. Ergo, Canada good.
That’s what the whole world says. Hillary Clinton just told MS NOW’s Rachel Maddow that Prime Minister Mark Carney could be the current leader of the free world. It was the Prime Minister who stood up in Davos and said in careful diplomatic language: Go sit on a wire brush, you vacuous mouth brake. We, the virtuous, flannel-clad folk of the bonspiel, the ketchup-flavored potato chips and the third-down punt, dare you.
Canada stands up to the bully. That’s a good thing, sure. But how do we do it, exactly? Canada wants economic independence. Canada wants to tell the US to suck eggs and pound sand. So anything we do to make ourselves economically strong and independent is good.
That means exploiting our natural resources. There was a helpful Cenovus TV ad recently that explains it all. More resource extraction, the Commercial explains, means more jobs, more taxes, more health care. Also more firemen, but they probably didn’t have time to participate in a 30-second advertisement. They mention that Canada “can provide the world with more energy from a secure, reliable trading partner.”
To see? We are the good guys. We are the most compassionate, reliable suppliers of fossil fuels. In this sense, our climate commitments would not be responsible. We would let our friends down. If the court takes away your license and fines your vehicle, Canada is the good friend who will quietly slip you a set of keys.
The Carney government’s climate record was pretty clear. The carbon tax was abolished, Bill C-5 exempted designated projects from green regulations, the government ended the Canada Greener Homes Loan program and eliminated zero-emission sales targets for motorists, reduced tree planting obligations, reduced funding for salmon conservation and agreed to drop the emissions cap for the oil and gas sector, among other dickish moves. Carney has made it clear he wants to deal with environmental regulations like Connor McDavid deals with a rookie defenseman. Frankly, Cenovus could have saved his money. Those ads push an open door.
When it comes to climate policy, Canada and the US are really on the same page – both countries are committed to doing nothing. So we stand against the mud? Or participate? If the victim is the environment, aren’t we really just standing around with a baseball bat, waiting our turn?
But go ahead, Canadian travelers, nahhhhh that Maple Leaf on your backpack. Wear that Canadian flag sweatshirt. Show your pride. Just don’t be surprised if you notice Antarctic penguins and green sea turtles giving you the stink eye. Not everyone buys our goody-two-shoes act. ![]()