Manitoba judge stays in charge in ‘rare’ decision after Mountie failed to disclose relationship with key witness

Drunk driving charges against a woman were stayed after an investigating RCMP officer appeared to have deliberately withheld information about his romantic relationship with a key witness, a Manitoba judge has ruled.

The officer’s relationship with the witness came to light by chance when the Crown prosecutor in the case ran into the pair at a Canadian tire, according to an October decision by provincial court Judge Victoria Cornick. This led to the woman withdrawing her guilty plea, and ultimately to a stay of proceedings, as her Charter rights were violated.

“These decisions are rare. They’re reserved for cases that are a clear issue, and I will say that I think this is a good example of something that sort of falls in that realm,” the woman’s lawyer, Matt Gould, told CBC News on Wednesday.

“In almost 20 years, I have not seen this behavior from the police. It highlights how vulnerable we all are…, how much we rely on the assumption that the police act with integrity, that they act in a straightforward manner, that they are honest, that they do not omit critical facts.”

RCMP are investigating a serious car accident outside of Flin Flon on March 4, 2023, Cornick wrote in her decision.

The woman was taken to hospital where lead investigator Const. Christopher Chelmecki learned in an interview that she had been drinking, Cornick wrote.

Officers sought evidence that the woman had been drinking, but hospital staff told them they needed a production order to access her medical records.

Matt Gould, seen here in a file photo, says it was “appalling” how easy it was for the officers’ statements to go unnoticed. (CBC)

About a month later, another officer, Corp. Jordan Tost told Chelmecki that two nurses at Flin Flon Hospital were potential witnesses and suggested that Chelmecki interview them, the decision said.

The lead investigator followed Tost’s request and interviewed the two nurses, who provided some evidence of the alleged alcohol consumption, Cornick wrote. Those statements were sent to Tost, who filed a production order for the woman’s medical records, the decision said.

At no time during the investigation did Tost reveal that he was in a romantic relationship with any of the nurses he told Chelmecki to interview, Cornick wrote.

Tost also initially said he did not remember having a conversation with Chelmecki about interviewing the nurses, Cornick wrote, only to later deny it completely.

Gould said they challenged the methods police used to secure the woman’s medical records in court, and a hearing was scheduled in July 2024 to challenge the validity of a warrant.

The defense demanded that Tost and the two nurses be examined during the hearing, but the court only allowed Tost to take the stand.

Tost’s relationship with the nurse was not disclosed on cross-examination during the hearing, and the production order was upheld, Cornick wrote.

The woman entered a guilty plea to driving with a blood-alcohol concentration above the legal limit, causing bodily harm — a plea that would have resulted in prison time, Cornick wrote.

Tost’s relationship with the nurse was not disclosed until May 2025, Cornick wrote, when Crown prosecutor Kameron Hutchinson ran into the two at Canadian Tire.

Tost initially explained that “he did not consider the relationship relevant to the investigation,” Cornick wrote, later saying he did not consider it at all. He also denied discussing the investigation with the nurse, the judge wrote.

The woman was allowed to withdraw her guilty plea last January.

A building with vehicles parked in front of it on a snowy day.

One RCMP officer told the other that there were two nurses at Flin Flon Hospital who were potential witnesses. (Eric Westhaver/CBC)

Cornick wrote that while there is no evidence to suggest the nurse provided inaccurate or fabricated information, the omission prevented the judge who authorized the production order from making a fully informed decision.

“The publication of the relationship would have allowed the investigation as [the nurse] came to be identified as a witness, which Cpl. Tost knew about her potential evidence prior to the interview, and whether relevant communications or qualifications were missing from the account presented to the authorized justice,” Cornick wrote.

The deliberate omission also compromised the July 2024 hearing, the judge wrote, when the court rejected the defense’s request to examine the two nurses.

“It is unnecessary to find that full disclosure would have defeated the production order with certainty,” Cornick wrote. “What is clear is that the review process has been subverted in a substantial way.”

Cornick also raised concerns that the omission was never deliberately disclosed, adding that the process “cannot rely on random public meetings as a safeguard against miscarriages of justice.”

There are no rules against evidence coming from one officer’s significant other, Gould said, noting that was never the main focus of the case.

“The concern was the lack of clarity, the omission of this information, the court’s acknowledgment that this information was not provided,” he said. “The information didn’t make it to court and it absolutely should have.”

While the public deserves to see justice for the alleged criminal conduct that left a victim suffering life-changing injuries, Cornick said the fairness and integrity of the justice system is more important to protect.

Like Cornick, Gould said that information about the relationship that comes to light by sheer chance is concerning.

“It is not unimportant. The danger faced here is quite simply years in prison,” he said. “It’s critical that the system works appropriately, and it’s terrifying. It should be horrifying to anyone to understand how easy it would have been for this to go unnoticed.”

The lawyer said he hopes this decision will prevent abuse of power from happening in the future.

“There will be real consequences for the officer, in my opinion, and the RCMP,” Gould said. “The impact on the credibility of this officer cannot be underestimated.”

Leave a Comment