Henry Nell’s career pushed his body to the limit. He played rugby professionally in his native South Africa. He then moved to the United States and began playing arena football, an indoor version of American football played on a slightly smaller field. He played for various teams across two leagues, always serving as a kicker.
In 2021, he started to feel some stiffness in his knee. Nell brushed it off as a strained muscle. If it didn’t go away, he assumed it was a sign of aging. But in 2025, when he was playing for the Albany Firebirds, the team trainer recommended an X-ray.
The scan showed a mass behind his knee. Nell tried to convince herself that it was just a cyst or a pocket of fluid. But it was diagnosed as parosteal osteosarcoma – a rare, slow-growing type of bone cancer. The tumor had been growing for years, the doctors said.
Hearing the word “cancer” wasn’t the scariest part, Nell said. The terror came when he met with a local oncologist who recommended amputation.
“I felt that nothing could get better as everything turned out. My sports career is in danger. My whole rest of my life is in danger,” Nell recalls. “If we have to amputate my leg, what are the next 60, 70 years of my life? How will this affect my family? Is my wife going to push me into a wheelchair? All these thoughts ran through my head. It was one of the most terrifying times I’ve ever experienced.”
A second opinion and a complex plan
Nell and his wife, a physical therapist, wanted a second opinion. They traveled to New York City to meet with Dr. Nicola Fabbri, a surgical oncologist and chief of the division of musculoskeletal oncology surgery at NYU Langone Health, who specializes in complex limb-conserving surgery.
Fabbri proposed a plan that could treat Nell’s cancer and keep her leg. Parosteal osteosarcoma occurs on the surface of the bone. Fabbri would remove just enough bone to make sure the tumor was gone and couldn’t grow back, then support Nell’s knee with cadaver bone and metal plates.
“We sat for almost an hour, and the last 10 minutes of us there, I was just in tears,” Nell recalled. “I couldn’t even talk to the man. I felt so bad, but I just cried because there was hope.”
Fabbri felt sure he could help Nell keep his leg, but wasn’t sure about his athletic career. The surgical plan posed a risk to two important ligaments: the anterior cruciate ligament, or ACL, and posterior cruciate ligament, or PCL. Removing the necessary bone and tissue could damage them, Fabbri said. They even have to be removed completely.
The operation was planned for July 2025, three weeks after the end of the Nell season. When it came close, he hoped for the best.
“I was like, ‘I could keep all my gang. He will go, he will taste the cancer. Five hours later, we begin our recovery process,” Nell said. “But nothing like that actually happened.”
“This has never been done before”
It took Fabbri about 11 hours to complete Nell’s operation. When Nell woke up, Fabbri delivered exciting news: He had to remove both ligaments to cure the cancer.
When Nell heard this, his “world broke once again.” The development “has made it significantly more difficult to see the light at the end of the tunnel,” he said.
The rest of Fabbri’s plan was a success. Two metal plates, 12 screws and cadaver bone successfully supported Nell’s knee. And it was better than the amputation that was first suggested. After his spirits recovered, Nell began questioning Fabbri about the next steps. But Fabbri didn’t have the answers.
“I kept asking, ‘Do you think I’ll be able to play again? Do you think I can hit again?’ And his answer was: ‘You go to me and tell me. This has never been done before,” Nell said. “He was like, ‘If you go and do it, we can tell our next patient it’s possible.’
Six weeks after the operation, Nell was cleared to put weight on his leg. He surrounded himself with a team that could support his recovery, which included physical therapy and strength training. Fabbri monitored the regimen to make sure Nell wasn’t pushing too hard.
The pros estimated it would take Nell about 18 months to resume normal day-to-day function, and wouldn’t guess when he might be back on the field.
But within three months of the operation, Nell was doing well enough to jog and kick lightly. The small steps inspired him. He continued to tighten his regimen, taking careful notes with Fabbri about what he was doing and when.
Less than a year after the surgery, he was well enough to return to the field with the Kansas Barrels for their season opener. The team won at home, Nell said.
“It was a big moment in my life,” Nell said. “It’s something I’ll hold on to forever.”
“Leaving a Legacy”
Nell “rarely thinks about the legs” these days. He played for the Barrels, then with the Orlando Pirates. He and his wife recently went on a hiking trip to Peru. He will participate in another season of arena football in the spring of 2027. He will also start practicing rugby with a local team – “just to see if my body can still do it.”
Nell remains cancer-free, Fabbri said. Because the entire osteosarcoma has been removed, the chances of recurrence are low, Fabbri said, adding that the longer Nell goes without a recurrence, the better the chance he will never have one.
Nell said he hopes his experience gives hope to the next person who receives a seemingly devastating diagnosis.
“In the football world, everybody talks about leaving a legacy, and what have you done for the game, and I’ve thought about that for a long time,” Nell said. “For me, it’s if I can just help one person or change the life of a person who feels hopeless right now.”


