LONDON – When European nations said they wanted greater involvement in the Ukraine peace talks, that was almost certainly not what they had in mind.
Europe has long had more say in negotiations to end the Russian war, fearing Washington and Moscow. They fear a deal favorable to President Vladimir Putin – who will meet President Donald Trump and Chinese leader Xi Jinping at a historic three-way meeting in Shenzhen, China, on Wednesday.
The good news for them is that the US says it is now pushing to include Europe in the next round of diplomacy. The bad news, say governments, officials and foreign policy analysts, is the alarming new proposal from Trump’s team: that the entire future of European security should also be up for discussion – the same demand that Putin has been pushing for years.
For the Russian leader, redrawing Europe’s security map means reducing NATO’s presence, correcting what he sees as injustices imposed on Moscow after the collapse of the Soviet Union. A succession of senior European officials have slammed the idea, warning that Washington risks “walking into Moscow’s trap,” as Kaja Kallas, the European Union’s foreign policy chief, put it.
“This is all quite bizarre,” said former Estonian President Toomas Hendrik Ilves, summarizing this sentiment in an interview with NBC News on Monday.
It is not clear how or why the US came up with a maximalist demand that Putin first made in 2021, one that was widely rejected by Western governments months before Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine. But in recent days, as Washington ramps up its pressure for a breakthrough in peace talks, Russia and the United States have both revived the idea.
Jared Kushner, the president’s son-in-law and envoy, wrote on Friday that the talks should address the “broad European security arrangements after the war.”
Earlier this month, he lamented “decades of mistrust” and “competitive security concerns” between Russia and Europe, promising to address these by building a “durable framework for long-term European security and stability”. Kushner also emphasized that NATO remains central to European defense and that no country has a veto over another’s alliances.
Trump himself has also hinted that he is seeking a final deal that encompasses the entire continent. “It’s going to be a big deal and it’s going to involve more than Ukraine,” he told reporters in the Oval Office earlier this month. “I could even say that the whole of Europe could participate. It will be a big, beautiful agreement, and everyone will be delighted.”
Instead, the idea has been met with unease and dismay, seen by many in Europe as Putin’s hard-line war aims.
While Kushner described Europe and Russia as neighbors unable to resolve their differences, the historical record shows that the aggression was directed mainly in one direction. Russia seized Ukraine’s Crimean peninsula in 2014, then launched a full-scale invasion in 2022, while waging sabotage, cyberattacks and disinformation against the West.
Kushner’s proposal also touches on a central European fear: that Washington will pursue a deal at almost any price, even if that encourages Putin to expand his aggression.
“Why are two real estate agents pushing this idea?” Ilves said Kushner and Steve Witkoff, another Trump envoy, both made their fortunes in real estate before entering diplomacy.
“These people are not even diplomats,” said Ilves, who led his former Soviet republic from 2006 to 2016. “I’m not sure they have much of an idea of the long history of the development of the security architecture in Europe in relation to Russia.”
Asked about the criticism, Assistant White House press secretary Olivia Wales said the US proposal seeks to “strengthen existing European security arrangements, with NATO at the core, while developing practical mechanisms to prevent future conflict.”
Security guarantees for Ukraine “cannot be designed without understanding the broader security framework in which they operate,” she said in an email, adding that any final agreement must respect Europe and Ukraine’s sovereignty “and be agreed upon by the relevant parties.”
However, European officials are not nervous about Kushner’s statements.
Kallas, the EU foreign policy chief, described Russia’s maximalist war demands as “truly absurd,” while German Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul pointed out that “Europe has a security architecture – we don’t need a new one.”
Elsewhere, Lithuanian Foreign Minister Kęstutis Budrys said the rules were not the issue: “The problem is that Russia is breaking them.” And Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney was adamant that the “security architecture for free Europe is determined by free Europe and NATO, not by Russia.”
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy described the idea as “dangerous,” saying European security “should not be the main agenda.”
Ukraine believes that Russia is in no position to make such demands, as it has spent more than four years trying to win the war.
“At this stage, the most Putin can negotiate is a fair ceasefire along the current contact line,” said Ukrainian Foreign Minister Andriy Sybiha. And “frankly speaking, Europe does not need a new security order; it already exists, and Russia is constantly violating it.”
Kiev and its European backers also argue that a ceasefire must come before any peace talks, accusing Russia of standing by so it can bomb civilian infrastructure before the frigid winter.
If Europe accepts Russia’s demands for a wider continental security before there is a ceasefire, Moscow will “try to create the impression that it is our fault that the war continues, because we do not want to accept all their demands,” said Sven Biscop, director of the Egmont Institute, a Belgian think tank.
He said he believed dialogue with Russia was a good thing, a view echoed by influential Finnish President Alexander Stubb, who said in an interview with the Financial Times published Tuesday that it was “irresponsible” to push talks with Putin to the United States, which he said could lead to cutting up Europe into spheres of influence.
Back in Washington, the top Democrat on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, Sen. Jeanne Shaheen, DN.H., urged Trump’s team to reject Putin’s claims.
The Russian leader not only wanted control of Ukraine, but “he wants to redesign NATO to accommodate his revisionist ambitions,” Shaheen said, adding that any discussion of European security infrastructure should be a “non-starter” for the United States, which “has benefited from the alliance.”
Amidst all this, any substantial progress towards ending the war remains elusive.
The latest round of talks between the United States, Russia and Ukraine in Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates, last week did not bring any major breakthrough. Kushner said Washington was working on what could be the largest prisoner exchange of the war, while reporting that Russia had agreed to give Europe a seat at the table during the next round.

Russia has not fully confirmed that, instead saying it needs to “understand from the Europeans themselves” what they “can contribute to the peace process” before allowing them to join, Putin’s spokesman Dmitry Peskov told reporters on Monday.
There was some internal wrangling between the European nations about who could represent them. The leaders agreed on a team made up of the UK (which will leave the EU in 2020), France, Germany, Italy and Poland, in addition to representatives from the European Commission and the European Council. Kallas himself was left by the team.
“I don’t know which of the current leaders could be a reasonable dialogue partner,” Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov told the state news agency Tass on Monday.
He compared the selected group of European countries to “Quartet”, a satirical poem by the Russian author Ivan Krylov. In it, a monkey, a donkey, a goat and a bear blame their failure to form a string quartet on the seating arrangement rather than their lack of musical ability.
That involved at least agreeing to a seating arrangement.