It is urgent on a Saturday evening at 7 o’clock in a center. A ten-year-old boy is “very bad” with severe tonsillitis and clearly needs antibiotics. Just before I (Rebecca Payne) go out to find an appropriate medicine, I ask his mother, “Does he have allergies?”
“Yes,” she says. “He can’t have penicillin or anything ending in -mycin.”
Finding the right treatment will be difficult. Penicillin and clarithromycin are the first-choice antibiotics for tonsillitis, and the alternatives are not recommended as first-line treatments. With an unwell child and a worried mother, this is not the ideal time to investigate an allergy history that goes back years.
This scenario is a surprisingly common problem. About one in 20 children in the United States has a penicillin allergy recorded in their medical records. But research suggests that most children labeled as allergic to penicillin are not actually allergic.
In our recent article in the British Journal of General Practice, we explain how GPs can identify children who have been wrongly labeled as allergic and remove inaccurate entries from their medical records. A structured conversation with families about what happened when the allergy was first noticed can help determine if the child really had an allergic reaction.
Why keep allergy labels
Many childhood antibiotic allergy labels begin during viral infections. Viruses can cause rashes that appear while a child is taking antibiotics. Parents and doctors may assume that the drug caused the rash, when the real cause was the virus. Vomiting, headache, fever and joint pain can also be mistaken for signs of an allergy.
Once an allergy is added to a child’s medical record, it can be difficult to remove. The label can follow them into adulthood, even if they were never allergic in the first place.
This is important because it means that children are at risk of receiving antibiotics that are less effective and that kill a much wider range of bacteria than necessary. This puts them at risk for infection by superbugs such as methicillin-resistant ones Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) and other pathogens such as . The consequences can be longer hospital stays and higher healthcare costs.
But there is a way to tackle the problem. Removing an incorrect allergy label from a medical record is known as “de-labeling”. Our recent article describes how GPs can work with families to establish what actually happened when a child was first labeled as allergic.
UK guidance already provides a framework to remove inaccurate penicillin allergy labels in hospitals. Research has also shown that a structured approach works safely in primary care outpatient clinics. In that 2024 study, 91% of evaluated children removed their allergy tags.
Photoroyalty/Shutterstock
How GPs can remove labels
A careful conversation can help GPs place children into three groups, depending on their symptoms and medical history.
The first group includes children whose original symptoms were never typical of an allergy, those who have since taken the same antibiotic without problems and those who are labeled allergic simply because another family member has an allergy. In these cases, the label can be removed without further tests or a specialist referral. Families can then be reassured that their child can take the medication.
The second group included children who developed a mild rash but had no serious symptoms, such as shortness of breath or feeling faint. After a careful evaluation, a doctor may prescribe a single dose of antibiotic for the child to take at home. The family is then contacted after a week to check for a reaction. If there was no reaction, the allergy label can be removed. This approach must be supervised by a professional such as a GP or practice pharmacist. Parents should never try to give their child an antibiotic again without medical advice.
The third group includes children who have had a severe reaction, such as anaphylaxis or a serious rash that affects the mouth or other moist areas of the body. Children with severe or poorly controlled asthma may also need specialist assessment. These children should be referred to a pediatric allergy or immunology service. It is essential that children with a true allergy do not receive the medication that caused it.
Read more: Antibiotic resistance is a growing problem, but solutions exist – expert Q&A
Sticking to an unsafe allergy label may feel like the safest option for parents and healthcare professionals. But leaving a false label in place also carries risks. The review can help families understand which medications their child can safely take and allow doctors to choose the most appropriate treatment if they become ill. Reducing unnecessary use of broader-spectrum antibiotics also helps tackle antibiotic resistance, which helps keep these drugs effective for everyone.
If your child has been told they are allergic to an antibiotic, ask your GP if the diagnosis could be checked, ideally if it is positive. If the label is removed, you should receive a clear explanation and written confirmation. The change should also be shared with other relevant health professionals. In this way, an assumption made years earlier is less likely to dictate a child’s future treatment.