Listen to this article
Estimated 4 minutes
The audio version of this article is generated by AI-based technology. Misunderstandings may occur. We work with our partners to continuously review and improve results.
A Manitoba judge has taken the “extraordinary and unusual” step of ordering the NDP government to reveal who made the decision to exclude Tesla Motors Canada from the province’s electric car rebate program — and explain why that decision was made.
In an order issued November 13, Court of King’s Bench Justice Elissa Neville gave the Wab Kinew government 10 days to produce “a complete record” of the decision-making process that disqualifies anyone who purchased Tesla vehicles after March 19, 2025, from qualifying for Manitoba’s EV rebates.
This means the NDP government has until Monday to explain the decision, which Tesla initially asked the court to overturn in May.
For the past six months, Tesla has argued that the decision was unreasonable, non-transparent and unfair, as the company claims that it is not clear who actually decided to exclude Tesla from the EV discount program and whether this person was legally authorized to make this decision.
The government, in turn, argued that the exclusion could not be reviewed in court because it was a funding decision.
In her order, Neville said she can’t make a determination without knowing who made the decision and said the NDP government has shown “an insane coyness” about the decision-making process.
“The disputed record submitted to the court sheds no light on the question of who made Tesla’s exclusion decisions, how they made the decisions, why they made the decisions, and whether those decisions are reviewable,” Neville wrote.
“Respondents’ position appears to be effectively that the reviewability of the decision must be determined before identifying the decision maker and producing the record.”
The judge further noted that it is not routine for courts to order governments to explain the reasoning behind decisions.
“I recognize that respondents’ refusal to submit their record through an affidavit is an extraordinary and unusual remedy,” Neville wrote.
“That said, in the specific and unique circumstances of this case, where the respondents refuse to identify anyone as the decision maker, such an approach strikes me as the more practical and efficient means of ensuring that there is a clear and streamlined record before the court.”
Discounts were drawn on Budget Day 2025
Manitoba’s EV rebate rolled out in 2024 but was retroactive to 2023. It entitles Manitobans to purchase a new electric vehicle or plug-in hybrid priced under $70,000 at a $4,000 rebate. Used and leased EVs qualify for a $2,500 or $1,000 rebate, respectively.
At the provincial budget day in 2025, Finance Minister Adrien Sala said that Tesla would remove the EV rebate about “Trump proof of our economy” and a “commitment to be elbows up.” Chinese EVs were also ruled out at that time.

Manitoba Finance Minister Adrien Sala speaks to reporters on March 20, 2025, as he unveiled a provincial budget that excluded Tesla from EV rebates. (Jason Empson/CBC)
Tesla argued that this exclusion was against the stated purpose of the EV rebate program and also cost consumers $560,000.
During a court hearing in October, Tesla’s legal counsel noted that Prime Minister Wab Kinew said in 2025 that Tesla CEO Elon Musk should “get Donald Trump to stop the tariffs, and then we can talk about the EV rebate.”
In her order, Justice Neville noted “in the absence of a proper record, the applicant says that it only has media reports and public comments from the Manitoba Premier, through which the rationale for Tesla’s exclusion decision is captured.
The province, she noted, viewed the EV rebate change as a policy decision under the government’s spending power.
“The applicant has the right to challenge a decision that affects his interests. The respondents intend to argue in this case that the decision that the applicant is challenging cannot be reviewed because it is a political decision,” she wrote.
“I can’t make that decision without knowing who made the decision. For some reason, the respondents say it’s up to the court to make that decision, even though the respondents have neither taken a stand nor provided the information necessary for me to do so.”
A government motion to strike Tesla’s application will be heard at the same time as the application, Neville said.
Tesla’s Winnipeg legal counsel declined further comment.
The NDP government also declined comment.